Who leads, who lags on sustainable finance coverage

ESG, sustainability, influence, local weather — whichever focus fits you — the Inflation Discount Act in all probability felt like a giant win. 

However sustainability wins have a tendency to supply short-lived celebrations. Two minutes into the occasion this week, the primary “yeah, however” calls amid the cheers reminded us (rightfully so) that we’re dancing on the point of a mass extinction. One of many extra highly effective “yeah, buts” in non-public sector sustainability is the mismatch between the story a corporation tells its stakeholders and the one its lobbyists and commerce teams inform elected officers. 

Take Massive Tech, now captured by the awkward MAMAA moniker. These firms get positioned as ESG darlings in public discourse and funding fund holdings alike. Working knowledge facilities on carbon-free power 24/7 by 2030 is formidable, good for the local weather and good for enterprise — an archetypal sustainability win. However contemplate Massive Tech’s meager 4 p.c annual spend on federal local weather coverage lobbying, and the aura of ambition dims. 

The identical applies to finance, and possibly much more so. “Engagement” is touted by the funding trade as a — if not the — key technique to get to web zero. Take, for instance, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink’s 2022 Letter to CEOs, the place he targeted explicitly on the agency’s rising Funding Stewardship workforce. 

However whereas sustainability-minded traders comparable to Inexperienced Century, Trillium and Walden have been tenacious and constant in pushing portfolio firms on ESG efficiency, the vast majority of the bigger companies “say they interact, nevertheless it’s only a good dialog, as a result of they don’t have an escalation path,” as As You Sow CEO Andrew Behar informed me. 

A lot consideration has been given to institutional traders’ engagement with portfolio firms on ESG points. However in such a dynamic regulatory and coverage setting for sustainable finance, surprisingly much less has targeted on traders’ personal coverage engagement.

There will likely be growing consideration paid to what’s being stated out of each side of the mouth by monetary companies firms about ESG progress in portfolios and in coverage. 

Local weather change suppose tank InfluenceMap has developed the “most complete evaluation on how the monetary sector is influencing climate-related monetary coverage.” I took a glance into the group’s Sustainable Finance Coverage Engagement platform to get a greater sense of how the most important monetary establishments are influencing the passage of worldwide sustainable finance insurance policies. 

The world is just not so black and white, however dividing leaders from laggards could be a useful heuristic. Listed below are a couple of takeaways on what finest and worst practices appear like. 


Multinational insurance coverage agency Aviva took the highest spot on the InfluenceMap record, with a grade of B. Aviva Buyers, the asset administration arm of the agency, led a lot of the agency’s coverage engagement.

A monetary agency that may hint its roots again to the seventeenth century doesn’t appear the probably candidate to be calling for main programs reform. However Aviva, as InfluenceMap factors out, is sort of alone in its assertion that the “approach cash flows by way of capital markets immediately is a product of evolution — not design … Had been we to create the markets from scratch immediately, we might create a really totally different system.”

On engagement towards Paris Settlement-aligned local weather coverage, Aviva checks the packing containers you’d hope to see from a sustainable finance chief. 

The agency has pushed for integration of the Job Power on Local weather-related Monetary Disclosures suggestions into European Union coverage and supported the necessary implementation of TCFD by the G7. It has additionally pushed governments to require firms to reveal their motion plans in aligning their enterprise methods and local weather targets, and was early in vocalizing its assist for the EU taxonomy, pushing additional for the taxonomy to incorporate environmentally damaging enterprise actions along with sustainable ones. 

The record of supported actions is simply too lengthy to enumerate in its entirety, however Steve Waygood, Aviva Buyers’ chief accountable funding officer, summed up its place effectively: “The monetary companies trade is failing. It’s clearly influential; we have to use that affect for macro-stewardship, not simply micro-stewardship with particular person firms.” A great instance of macro-stewardship is Aviva’s advocacy to mandate net-zero targets for central banks.

Of specific notice, too, Aviva has been an lively supporter of a elementary change that many within the institutional investor universe have been much less eager to the touch: The fiduciary obligation to behave in the very best monetary curiosity of shoppers ought to embrace ESG points.


The bottom grade — a D — was awarded to Ameriprise Monetary, which demonstrated restricted and, when exercised, blended engagement.

Whereas the agency acknowledges the chance local weather change poses to the monetary system, it hasn’t demonstrated curiosity in or assist for reform. Columbia Threadneedle, the asset administration arm of Ameriprise, opposed the EU’s sustainable finance motion plan, emphasizing that coverage of this nature ought to take care of operations in the actual economic system and never give attention to finance, and that such a taxonomy would create extra confusion than options.

That stated, Columbia Threadneedle did voice assist final 12 months for the Biden administration’s give attention to sustainable finance, saying, “It’s time for the U.S. to play catch up” on ESG coverage. 

One thing all of the D and D-plus grade recipients shared was a scarcity of element about engagement technique with policymakers and, importantly, a scarcity of disclosed memberships to influential commerce associations (particularly these identified to persistently foyer towards local weather laws). Or, when the memberships are recognized, few particulars are given about the kind of oblique affect on governance these roles have.

The important thing takeaway on each ends of the leader-laggard spectrum is — as with a lot within the sustainability transition — about elevated stakeholder consciousness and expectation. The function of finance in realizing the transition to a clear economic system is turning into clearer to stakeholders comparable to clients and workers, and growing consideration will likely be paid to what’s being stated out of each side of the mouth by monetary companies firms about ESG progress in portfolios and in coverage. 

Not each trade has an advocacy group comparable to ClimateVoice, however as the previous couple of years have seen, amid a rise in ambition from policymakers to enact climate-related monetary coverage, the contributions or opposition to progress on that entrance by traders and lenders will come extra carefully below the microscope. The notion that finance is pumping out greenwash is already heightened, and elevated scrutiny by organizations comparable to InfluenceMap will solely increase them.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.